Good
evening and welcome to an unseasonably cool Panhandle, It's kind of
hard to believe that it is June. Well we had a great Vacation Bible
School last week. We were down in numbers, but at least we had some
kids show up and that is a blessing. Most important we were able to
share with them about Christ Jesus and His love for them.
Here
we are the end of the Book of Genesis. Sounds kind of funny, the end
of the book of beginnings. We see the end of Jacob's days and
Joseph's as well. This also marks the end of the Patriarchs. Next
week we will look at Chapter 50 and the very last chapter of Genesis.
In chapter 48 we read about Jacob’s
last days and how he blessed the two sons of Joseph. You can imagine
the thrill of Jacob, as a grandfather, in blessing the sons of Joseph
when he had thought at one time that Joseph, his favorite son was
dead.
After Jacob saw the important position
of Joseph in Egypt and the way God had worked out the affairs of his
life, Jacob had occasion to rejoice.
Gen 48 At A Glance
I. Joseph, hearing of his father's
sickness, goes to visit him, and takes his two sons with him v. 1-2.
II. Jacob solemnly adopts his two
sons, and takes them for his own v. 3-7.
III. He blesses them v. 8-16.
IV. He explains and justifies the
crossing of his hands in blessing them v. 17-20.
V. He leaves a particular legacy to
Joseph v. 21-22.
(from
Matthew Henry's Commentary on the Whole Bible: New Modern Edition,
Electronic Database. Copyright (c) 1991 by Hendrickson Publishers,
Inc.)
Genesis 48:1-14
1
Some time later Joseph was told, "Your father is ill." So
he took his two sons Manasseh and Ephraim along with him. 2 When
Jacob was told, "Your son Joseph has come to you," Israel
rallied his strength and sat up on the bed.
3
Jacob said to Joseph, "God Almighty appeared to me at Luz in the
land of Canaan, and there he blessed me 4 and said to me, `I am going
to make you fruitful and will increase your numbers. I will make you
a community of peoples, and I will give this land as an everlasting
possession to your descendants after you.'
5
"Now then, your two sons born to you in Egypt before I came to
you here will be reckoned as mine; Ephraim and Manasseh will be mine,
just as Reuben and Simeon are mine. 6 Any children born to you after
them will be yours; in the territory they inherit they will be
reckoned under the names of their brothers. 7 As I was returning from
Paddan, to my sorrow Rachel died in the land of Canaan while we were
still on the way, a little distance from Ephrath. So I buried her
there beside the road to Ephrath" (that is, Bethlehem).
8
When Israel saw the sons of Joseph, he asked, "Who are these?"
9
"They are the sons God has given me here," Joseph said to
his father.
Then
Israel said, "Bring them to me so I may bless them."
10
Now Israel's eyes were failing because of old age, and he could
hardly see. So Joseph brought his sons close to him, and his father
kissed them and embraced them.
11
Israel said to Joseph, "I never expected to see your face again,
and now God has allowed me to see your children too."
12
Then Joseph removed them from Israel's knees and bowed down with his
face to the ground. 13 And Joseph took both of them, Ephraim on his
right toward Israel's left hand and Manasseh on his left toward
Israel's right hand, and brought them close to him. 14 But Israel
reached out his right hand and put it on Ephraim's head, though he
was the younger, and crossing his arms, he put his left hand on
Manasseh's head, even though Manasseh was the firstborn.
Joseph brought his two boys to his
father to receive his benediction. He arranged his sons so that
Jacob's right hand would rest upon Manasseh, the elder boy, and his
left hand upon Ephraim. Even though Jacob was old and almost blind,
he deliberately changed the positions of his hands by laying his
right hand on the head of the younger and his left hand on Manasseh.
While this was not the custom, Jacob knew what he was doing. When
Joseph tried to change his father's hands so that Manasseh would
receive the chief blessing (according to custom), he was informed
that Ephraim was destined to receive it (v. 19).
The patriarch's solemn blessing spoken
upon the sons of Joseph was as binding as a last will and testament.
In it Jacob included a prediction of future prominence for each of
the boys, but Ephraim's growth and effectiveness was to be far beyond
Manasseh's. (from The Wycliffe
Bible Commentary, Electronic Database. Copyright (c) 1962 by Moody
Press)
Genesis 48:15-22
15
Then he blessed Joseph and said,
"May
the God before whom my fathers
Abraham
and Isaac walked,
the
God who has been my shepherd
all
my life to this day,
16
the Angel who has delivered me from all harm
--may
he bless these boys.
May
they be called by my name
and
the names of my fathers Abraham and Isaac,
and
may they increase greatly
upon
the earth."
17
When Joseph saw his father placing his right hand on Ephraim's head
he was displeased; so he took hold of his father's hand to move it
from Ephraim's head to Manasseh's head. 18 Joseph said to him, "No,
my father, this one is the firstborn; put your right hand on his
head."
19
But his father refused and said, "I know, my son, I know. He too
will become a people, and he too will become great. Nevertheless, his
younger brother will be greater than he, and his descendants will
become a group of nations." 20 He blessed them that day and
said,
"In
your name will Israel pronounce this blessing:
`May
God make you like Ephraim and Manasseh.'"
So
he put Ephraim ahead of Manasseh.
21
Then Israel said to Joseph, "I am about to die, but God will be
with you and take you back to the land of your fathers. 22 And to
you, as one who is over your brothers, I give the ridge of land I
took from the Amorites with my sword and my bow."
When the aged man came to pronounce a
special blessing upon Joseph, he referred to God in a threefold
title: The God of our fathers, the God who shepherded me, and the
Angel of deliverance. Thus, the ancestral, the personal, and the
redemptive aspects of God were represented.
Hebrew (ro` eh) carries the idea of
shepherding (Psalms 23:1). The Angel which redeemed me from all evil
identifies this One with the Angel of Jehovah who comforted Hagar
(Genesis 16:7; 21:17) and who warned Abraham of the imminent
destruction of Sodom (Genesis 18); in other words, this "Angel"
was the Lord himself in his OT manifestation.
Jacob said that Joseph was to possess
the special `shoulder' (shekem) or mountain slope of unusual value
(one portion above thy brethren). This probably refers to the
property Jacob had acquired from Hamor, although Genesis 34 shows
that Jacob repudiated the manner in which it was first taken. It was
probably recaptured by Jacob later from the Amorites (John 4:5).
(from The Wycliffe Bible
Commentary, Electronic Database. Copyright (c) 1962 by Moody Press)
Chapter 49, in many respects, is
one of the most remarkable chapters in the Bible. This chapter is
prophetic and tells what will happen to the twelve sons of Jacob when
they become tribes. The different experiences which were to happen to
each tribe were prophetic when given, but today they have become
largely historical. This chapter should be considered along with
Deuteronomy 33 where Moses on his death bed spoke concerning the
twelve tribes.
This chapter is a prophecy; the closes
to it that we have was that of Noah, Genesis 9:25, etc. Jacob is on
his death-bed, making his will. He had put it off until now, because
dying men's words are more apt to make deep impressions, and to be
remembered long after they are spoken. Now he spoke the words given
to him by the Holy Spirit, who chose this time, so that divine
strength might be perfected in his weakness.
The twelve sons of Jacob were, in their
day, men of renown. Now they would be heads of the twelve tribes of
Israel. After such a shaky past they were now men of renown and we
find their names upon the gates of the New Jerusalem, Revelation
21:12. In the prospect of this their dying father says something
remarkable of each son, or of the tribe that bore his name.
It was a comfort to Jacob, now that he
was dying, to see all his children about him, and none of them
missing, though he had sometimes thought himself bereaved. It was
good for them to attend to Jacob in his last moments, they learned
from him how to die, as well as how to live. What he said to each he
said in front of all the rest. His calling on them to gather together
one more time indicated both a precept to them to unite in love, (to
keep together, not to mingle with the Egyptians, not to forsake the
assembling of themselves together,) and a prediction that they should
not be separated from each other, as Abraham's sons and Isaac's were,
but should be integrated, and all make one people. (from
Matthew Henry's Commentary on the Whole Bible: New Modern Edition,
Electronic Database. Copyright (c) 1991 by Hendrickson Publishers,
Inc.)
Gen 49 At A Glance
I. The preface v. 1-2.
II. The prediction concerning each
tribe v. 3-28.
III. The charge repeated concerning his
burial v. 29-32.
IV. His death v. 33.
(from
Matthew Henry's Commentary on the Whole Bible: New Modern Edition,
Electronic Database. Copyright (c) 1991 by Hendrickson Publishers,
Inc.)
Genesis 49:1-2
1
Then Jacob called for his sons and said: "Gather around so I can
tell you what will happen to you in days to come.
2
"Assemble and listen, sons of Jacob;
listen
to your father Israel.
The groundwork of Jacob's prophecy was
supplied partly by the natural character of his twelve sons, and
partly by the divine promise which had been given by the Lord to him
and to his fathers Abraham and Isaac, and that not merely in these
two points, the numerous increase of their seed and the possession of
Canaan, but in its entire scope, by which Israel had been appointed
to be the recipient and medium of salvation for all nations.
On this foundation the Spirit of God
revealed to the dying patriarch Israel the future history of his
seed, so that he recognized in the characters of his sons the future
development of the tribes proceeding from them, and with prophetic
clearness assigned to each of them its position and importance in the
nation into which they were to expand in the promised inheritance.
Thus he predicted to the sons what would happen to them "in the
last days," lit., "at the end of the days" and not
merely at some future time. (from
Keil & Delitzsch Commentary on the Old Testament: New Updated
Edition, Electronic Database. Copyright (c) 1996 by Hendrickson
Publishers, Inc.)
Genesis
49:3-4
3
"Reuben, you are my firstborn,
my
might, the first sign of my strength,
excelling
in honor, excelling in power.
4
Turbulent as the waters, you will no longer excel,
for
you went up onto your father's bed,
onto
my couch and defiled it.
Reuben, the first-born of Leah,
had enjoyed per-eminence among his brothers. But he forfeited his
natural rights. His place as the favored first-born was given to
Joseph. His privileges as priest were to pass to the sons of Levi.
His right to be the head of the tribes of Israel, i.e., his kingly
right, would go to Judah. Thus Reuben, endowed with dignity,
first-born rights, and natural excellencies, would forfeit every
place of power and influence because of the instability of his
character. His unspeakable sin with Bilhah gave evidence of moral
weakness that spelled ruin. His uncontrolled passion (unstable as
water) is pictured in the Hebrew as "water
without restraint pouring down in a foaming torrent"
(v. 4). Though capable of dreams and plans and good
intentions, he could not be counted on to carry them through to
completion.
Genesis 49:5-7
5
"Simeon and Levi are brothers--
their
swords are weapons of violence.
6
Let me not enter their council,
let
me not join their assembly,
for
they have killed men in their anger
and
hamstrung oxen as they pleased.
7
Cursed be their anger, so fierce,
and
their fury, so cruel!
I
will scatter them in Jacob
and
disperse them in Israel.
Simeon and Levi are brethren;
instruments of cruelty are in their habitations. Simeon and Levi,
Jacob's second and third sons by Leah, were brothers in violence. The
old father could never forget their cruel massacre of the
Shechemites. They revealed their true characters that day, for they
violently attacked and destroyed men they had previously made
helpless by strategy and deceit. At that time they were censured by
their father. Now, as he lay on his death bed, they heard the biting
words of his curse: I will divide them in Jacob and scatter them in
Israel (v. 7 b). They were not to have territory they could call
their own, but would be dispersed among the other tribes. In Canaan
this curse was fulfilled: the Simeonites were swallowed up into the
tribe of Judah; the Levites had no territory assigned to them, but
served as ministers of the sanctuary and teachers of Israel.
Genesis 49:8-12
8
"Judah, your brothers will praise you;
your
hand will be on the neck of your enemies;
your
father's sons will bow down to you.
9
You are a lion's cub, O Judah;
you
return from the prey, my son.
Like
a lion he crouches and lies down,
like
a lioness--who dares to rouse him?
10
The scepter will not depart from Judah,
nor
the ruler's staff from between his feet,
until
he comes to whom it belongs
and
the obedience of the nations is his.
11
He will tether his donkey to a vine,
his
colt to the choicest branch;
he
will wash his garments in wine,
his
robes in the blood of grapes.
12
His eyes will be darker than wine,
his
teeth whiter than milk.
Judah, Jacob's fourth son by Leah,
received the first unqualified praise from the old patriarch. He
carried the hope of Israel upon his person. Having neither birthright
nor exceptional dignity nor spiritual powers, he would emerge as the
powerful leader of a people who could enthusiastically admire and
praise him. (Judah means praise.) He would be feared by his enemies,
for as a lion he would pursue them relentlessly until victory was
his. Then, having completed his mission, he would retire to his
mountain fastness to rest in the security of a stronghold that none
could take. He would grasp in his hand the scepter or baton that
would symbolize his mastery in the roles of warrior, king, and judge.
Any nation could be happy, secure, and honored with Judah as its head
and protector. (from The Wycliffe
Bible Commentary, Electronic Database. Copyright (c) 1962 by Moody
Press)
If this interpretation is correct, then
Jacob's words here constitute one of the earliest appearances of the
Messianic promise. That which Jacob was enabled to see was a clear
picture of Judah's inheritance. But the full realization of God's
purposes would not be enjoyed until the ideal ruler, the Messiah,
demonstrated perfect sovereignty. Fortunately, the Old Testament
presents a distinct line of prophecies-beginning at Genesis 3:15 and
continuing through the Psalms and the Prophets-regarding Messiah's
coming to reign as King of kings.
Jacob saw Judah as the father of the
royal tribe that would exert power and leadership over all the
others. Through catastrophes and difficult times, God would see to it
that the scepter would remain in the tribe of Judah until the ideal
ruler, the Messiah, would come. (from
The Wycliffe Bible Commentary, Electronic Database. Copyright (c)
1962 by Moody Press)
Genesis 49:13
13
"Zebulun will live by the seashore
and
become a haven for ships;
his
border will extend toward Sidon.
Jacob's sixth son by Leah, was to be
situated in a place where commercial activity and prosperity would be
possible. This may mean that territory along the seacoast was to be
allotted to the tribe of Zebulun. Or, it may mean that
prosperity would come to the descendants of Zebulun because of their
proximity to the Phoenicians, who had unlimited access to the trade
routes.
Jacob mentions Sidon as being there. It
is also possible that Jacob's prediction was not fully carried out
when the final division of the land was made. In the song of Deborah
(Judges 5) the people of Zebulun are warmly commended for their
valorous stand against Sisera and his army.
Genesis
49:14-15
14
"Issachar is a rawboned donkey
lying
down between two saddlebags.
15
When he sees how good is his resting place
and
how pleasant is his land,
he
will bend his shoulder to the burden
and
submit to forced labor.
Issachar, Jacob's fifth son by Leah, is
represented as a strong, ox-like lover of rest and quiet. The word
(hamor), literally, (bony ass), does not refer to the wild, fleet,
high-spirited animal that would catch the eye of the onlooker. On the
contrary, it designates a powerful beast of burden that submits
himself to the galling yoke without complaint in order that he may be
free to lie quietly in ease and comfort. Thus Jacob was predicting
that the tribe of Issachar would submit to the Canaanite invader, who
would fasten the yoke upon them. Instead of fighting, the men of this
tribe would submissively allow themselves to become slaves of the
peoples of the land. They would prefer shame and slavery to
courageous action.
Genesis 49:16-18
16
"Dan will provide justice for his people
as
one of the tribes of Israel.
17
Dan will be a serpent by the roadside,
a
viper along the path,
that
bites the horse's heels
so
that its rider tumbles backward.
18
"I look for your deliverance, O LORD.
Dan, the first son of Bilhah, would
become a strong defender of his own people. He would plead their
cause and defend and help them in their struggle for independence.
The tribe would be small, but they would be greatly feared by
neighbors who might seek to trample upon them. Jacob called Dan a
horned snaked in the path (a serpent by the way, v. 17), to cause
terror and inflict quick, fatal wounds. Hebrew (nahash) signifies not
only a snake in the grass, but a venomous reptile with deadly fangs.
That is, Dan would be exceedingly dangerous to his foes.
In later times members of the tribe of
Dan fulfilled these words with remarkable accuracy. After a time in
their original territory, the Danites moved to the north and occupied
the northernmost point in Israel. These people were never
distinguished for their spiritual attainments. In 931 B.C. Jeroboam
set up a golden calf in Dan to provide opportunity for pagan worship.
Genesis 49:19
19
"Gad will be attacked by a band of raiders,
but
he will attack them at their heels.
Gad was the first son of Leah's
handmaid, Zilpah. The aged patriarch recognized that the brave,
warlike spirit of Gad would be a strong help to his people in the
life in Canaan. Jacob predicted that Gad would need all his cunning,
courage, and persistence in fighting, because he would be harassed by
the continual attacks of desert tribes. Marauding bands would press
down upon him. Jacob made use of a play on words-Gad meaning a
troop-to indicate the ferocity and cruelty of the raiders from the
desert. He foretold that Gad would be victorious and would be able to
drive the enemy away. After the conquest of Canaan, the tribe of Gad
was stationed east of the Jordan.
Genesis
49:20
20
"Asher's food will be rich;
he
will provide delicacies fit for a king.
Asher, Zilpah's second son, carried a
name meaning (happy.) Jacob pictured him in a fertile field, where
wheat and wine and oil would be produced in plenteous measure. He
would be prosperous and would gain riches. The delicacies he would
produce would be fit for the table of a king. (Even the kings of Tyre
and Sidon would desire them.) The tribe of Asher witnessed the
fulfillment of that patriarchal prophecy.
Genesis 49:21
21
"Naphtali is a doe set free
that
bears beautiful fawns.
Naphtali, the second son of Bilhah,
would demonstrate a remarkable love of freedom; he was a hind let
loose, Jacob said. The illustration describes a wild, swift, graceful
animal that delights in the freedom provided by wooded hills and open
valleys. Naphtali was to have the run of God's great outdoors. He
giveth goodly words is, perhaps, a reference to the eloquent and
helpful discourses that would proceed from the mouths of men of this
tribe. Barak, because of his valor, became one of their prize
exhibits. In Judges 5:18 we read:
"Zebulun and Naphtali were a people that hazarded their lives
unto the death."
Genesis 49:22-26
22
"Joseph is a fruitful vine,
a
fruitful vine near a spring,
whose
branches climb over a wall.
23
With bitterness archers attacked him;
they
shot at him with hostility.
24
But his bow remained steady,
his
strong arms stayed limber,
because
of the hand of the Mighty One of Jacob,
because
of the Shepherd, the Rock of Israel,
25
because of your father's God, who helps you,
because
of the Almighty, who blesses you
with
blessings of the heavens above,
blessings
of the deep that lies below,
blessings
of the breast and womb.
26
Your father's blessings are greater
than
the blessings of the ancient mountains,
than
the bounty of the age-old hills.
Let
all these rest on the head of Joseph,
on
the brow of the prince among his brothers.
Joseph is a fruitful bough, even
a fruitful bough by a well; whose branches run over the wall: Joseph,
the first son of Rachel, received the highest praise of all the sons.
A man of vision, of dreams, of moral and spiritual strength, he
exemplified all that was best in the realm of OT living. In his
several roles as son, brother, slave, and administrator, he
demonstrated his superior character through his unwavering loyalty to
his God.
Jacob called Joseph a young fruit tree.
Hebrew (para) (fruitful bough) contains a play on the name "Ephraim."
The reference is to a vigorously growing tree or vine, connoting
vitality and youthfulness. As a result of being planted by a bubbling
fountain (well), it would continue to grow and bear fruit. In the dry
country, water made the difference between sterility and
fruitfulness. Moisture guaranteed fertility. A tree so strengthened
could be expected to throw its branches or its tendrils over the wall
in giving its plentiful fruit to the peoples of the earth.
(from
The Wycliffe Bible Commentary, Electronic Database. Copyright (c)
1962 by Moody Press)
As a result of this exceptional
prosperity, Joseph could expect bitter jealousy and hostility. The
archers would be busy in their furious attacks. This had been true in
Joseph's earlier days, when his brothers, embittered by envy, sought
to destroy him. Many years later, in the land of Canaan, the tribes
of Ephraim and Manasseh would encounter opposition and
persecution. They would have to have a living faith in Jehovah of
hosts, who had proved himself the all-sufficient God. Joseph knew him
and had leaned on him in every emergency.
Sorely grieved ... shot at ... hated,
translate three Hebrew words. Marar, in the piel form, means to
"provoke," "embitter," "harass." The
use of this piel form, plus the word (rabab) adds to the intensity of
the action and speaks of its repeated occurrence. The third word,
(satam), carries the idea of deep-seated hatred, along with active
persecution.
His bow abode in strength. In Joseph's
victories there had been evidences of the firm bow and the agile
hands, the special power given by the Lord. Jacob predicted that this
same supernatural help could be expected on the hills of Palestine.
The word translated firm or abode in strength, could well be rendered
(unmoved, enduring,) or ever-flowing. Jacob used the titles, Mighty
One of Jacob ... the God of thy father, and the Almighty ('El
Shadday), to portray the arm that would be so powerful, so
dependable, so quick and agile that no foe could resist it.
In simple faith he entrusted the tribe
of Joseph into divine hands, and in confident faith he foretold
certain victories over the enemies who awaited them. In addition to
the special powers in dealing with foes, the descendants of Joseph
were assured of bountiful blessings. From above, they would have
abundant rain and dew. From beneath, the soil would be supplied with
the ingredients that would make for food and harvests. By special
divine gift, the fertility among men and animals would provide for
the unending fruitfulness of the family. In short, Joseph would
always be considered a prince among his brothers (separate from
his brethren).
Hebrew (nezir) indicates "one set
apart," or, "one who is separated or consecrated for high
duties." The Nazarite was a man who had been given to God and by
special vow was irrevocably committed to him. Ephraim, his son, was
to have qualities that made for holy dedication to fulfill God's
purpose for one who was chosen to put into action the principles so
beautifully exemplified by Joseph. He was the prince among the tribes
of Israel.
(from
The Wycliffe Bible Commentary, Electronic Database. Copyright (c)
1962 by Moody Press)
Genesis 49:27
27
"Benjamin is a ravenous wolf;
in
the morning he devours the prey,
in
the evening he divides the plunder."
Benjamin, the younger son of
Rachel, was characterized as a fierce, dangerous wolf that could do
great damage. The wolf is keen and stealthy in his movements. At
night he slips silently among the sheep and makes off with his prize.
Hebrew (taraf) means (to tear into shreds.) The old English word
ravin means "to prey with rapacity." It speaks of fierce
cruelty.
The evening wolves could be as savage
and destructive in the early morning. At any time they were ready for
the fierce business of inhuman behavior. Ehud, Saul, and Jonathan
were among the later descendants of Benjamin who gave evidence of
their warlike powers. The men of this tribe became famous for their
bowmen and their slingers (cf. Judg 5:14; 20:16).
(from
The Wycliffe Bible Commentary, Electronic Database. Copyright (c)
1962 by Moody Press)
Genesis 49:28-33
28
All these are the twelve tribes of Israel, and this is what their
father said to them when he blessed them, giving each the blessing
appropriate to him.
29
Then he gave them these instructions: "I am about to be gathered
to my people. Bury me with my fathers in the cave in the field of
Ephron the Hittite, 30 the cave in the field of Machpelah, near Mamre
in Canaan, which Abraham bought as a burial place from Ephron the
Hittite, along with the field. 31 There Abraham and his wife Sarah
were buried, there Isaac and his wife Rebekah were buried, and there
I buried Leah. 32 The field and the cave in it were bought from the
Hittites."
33
When Jacob had finished giving instructions to his sons, he drew his
feet up into the bed, breathed his last and was gathered to his
people.
When Jacob had finished his address of
blessing, censure, and curse, he talked to his sons of his
approaching death. In his final instructions, he directed his sons to
take his body to Canaan for burial. Bury me with my fathers in the
cave, he said, that is in the field of Ephron (v. 29). He reminded
them that the family burial place already held the ashes of Abraham,
Sarah, Isaac, Rebekah, and Leah. Rachel was buried in a tomb near
Bethelehem (Genesis 35:19-20).
As soon as Jacob had finished his
directions, he gathered up his feet into the bed and, without a
struggle, yielded up his spirit (ruah) and passed into the presence
of those who had already gone into the other world (Sheol). The Old
Terstament saints were far from the New Testament conception of life
after death, but even in that early day they were aware of some
unusual perceptions as they stood in the presence of the deceased
members of the family. Sheol was the shadowy region where souls that
had left the mortal body continued their existence. (from
The Wycliffe Bible Commentary, Electronic Database. Copyright (c)
1962 by Moody Press)
Review Questions:
- What is unusual about Jacob’s blessings on Joseph’s sons?
- Who does Jacob call to his bed side? Why?
- Again there is something unusual about Jacob’s blessings to his sons, what is it?
- What request does Jacob make regarding his burial?
No comments:
Post a Comment